PROS: Located right in Smithville. Beautiful view of the lake and picnic tables outside. They have a large menu and a variety of huge slices to choose from when you want a quick bite. They have daily dinner specials. Their spinach and artichoke dip was delicious. They gave it to me as a to-go order by accident but it came out very fresh and I think that's the secret to this place.. order everything to-go even if you plan on sitting. The girl behind the counter was very sweet, patient, smiled and made recommendation. They do bring the food to your table instead of calling you back up to the counter. CONS: I am a buffalo chicken pizza connoisseur as I get it everywhere I go. I can't stress enough how many buffalo chicken slices I've had in my life. Unfortunately, it wasn't good at all for me. I wish my review was different as they say they're known for this type of pizza. The buffalo sauce was sweet, the chicken was chewy and the slices were very limp. I did not expect the sweetness but kept an open mind about it. When I was almost done eating my slice, I couldn't finish it because it was too sweet for me. I can appreciate how they put a spin on it like (sweet heat.) Lastly, I know flies are annoying and hard to handle in the summer, but several of them swarming around our table was ridiculous. Eating while swatting flies off our food and face the whole time was not my idea of dining in. Overall it wasn't that bad and I might give it another try one day.
Overview
When you're craving a delicious meal in Hammonton, New Jersey, look no further than Costello's Pizzeria & Wings. Nestled along the 30 N White Horse Pike, this local gem offers an unbeatable combination of mouth-watering pizza, juicy wings, and a welcoming atmosphere that’s perfect for both a quick bite and a family dinner. Whether you're a local or just passing through, a visit to Costello’s is an experience you won’t soon forget.
One of the highlights of Costello’s is their diverse menu, which truly has something for everyone. Of course, the standout is their pizza, which is consistently made fresh with the finest ingredients. From the classic margherita to the specialty pies like the buffalo chicken pizza, there's a flavor for every palate. The crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, providing the ideal foundation for the generous layers of cheese and toppings. One of my personal favorites is their white pizza, which comes loaded with ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic-a simple yet irresistible combination.
But the pizza isn’t the only thing that draws people in. The wings at Costello’s are another reason why this spot has earned such a loyal following. Whether you prefer them mild, medium, hot, or extra spicy, the wings are always cooked to perfection. Each one is coated in a rich, flavorful sauce that clings to the crispy skin. They’re served with a side of blue cheese or ranch, depending on your preference. If you're a fan of flavorful, tender wings, you'll understand why these are often considered some of the best in the area.
If you’re in the mood for something beyond pizza and wings, Costello’s also offers a variety of subs, pasta dishes, and salads. The pasta is always fresh, and the hearty portions ensure that you’ll leave full and satisfied. Their spaghetti and meatballs is a classic comfort dish, served with a homemade marinara sauce that’s packed with rich, savory flavors. And if you’re looking for something light, their garden salad is crisp and refreshing, paired with a tangy dressing that perfectly complements the greens.
What sets Costello's apart from other pizzerias and diners in the area is the warm, friendly service. The staff makes you feel right at home, whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor. The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, making it an ideal place for families to enjoy a meal together or for friends to catch up over some delicious pizza and wings. Many customers also appreciate the cozy, no-fuss setting, which allows them to enjoy their food in a laid-back environment.
Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings is not just about the food-it’s about the experience. The restaurant has earned its reputation through consistent quality and a dedication to providing a great dining experience for everyone who walks through its doors. Regulars often rave about the consistency of the food, noting that every visit is as satisfying as the last. This is a true testament to the care and attention to detail that goes into every dish served.
Whether you're a fan of traditional pizza or you're looking to try something a little different, Costello's Pizzeria & Wings has a wide variety of menu options to satisfy any craving. With fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and a friendly atmosphere, it’s no wonder this place has become a staple in Hammonton. The next time you find yourself in the area, be sure to stop by and see what all the fuss is about. You won’t regret it!
Good to know
Service options
âś“ No-contact delivery âś“ Delivery âś“ Drive-through âś“ Takeaway âś“ Dine-inPopular for
âś“ Lunch âś“ Dinner âś“ Solo diningAccessibility
âś“ Wheelchair-accessible car park âś“ Wheelchair-accessible entrance âś“ Wheelchair-accessible seatingOfferings
âś“ Comfort food âś“ Quick bite âś“ Small platesDining options
âś“ Lunch âś“ Dinner âś“ Catering âś“ DessertAmenities
âś“ ToiletAtmosphere
âś“ CasualCrowd
âś“ Groups âś“ TouristsPayments
âś“ Credit cards âś“ Debit cards âś“ NFC mobile payments âś“ Credit cardsChildren
âś“ Good for kids âś“ Kids' menuParking
âś“ Free of charge street parking âś“ Free parking lot âś“ ParkingPhotos
Location
Reviews
My go to for lunch, not only is the staff amazing but so is the food. Large authentic portions and nicely priced. Absolutely I adore the young lady in the front she is such a doll. Favorite is their pizza next to their salads !
Ordered a fugggitboutit pie. Very filling. Lots of flavor. If I town again would get it again